In Loving Memory of John McNally
Ithaca, NY — A Life Dedicated to Teaching, Coaching, and Inspiring Others
The Ithaca community is mourning the heartbreaking loss of John McNally, a beloved educator, coach, mentor, and friend who passed away this week. His sudden departure leaves a deep void in the hearts of his family, colleagues, students, and the broader community he served so passionately for decades.
John was a cornerstone of the Ithaca City School District, where he spent many years as a physical education teacher at Boynton Middle School. Known for his magnetic energy and unwavering positivity, John didn’t just teach P.E.—he instilled in his students the values of perseverance, teamwork, and self-belief. His classroom and athletic fields were safe, joyful spaces where every student felt seen, encouraged, and capable.
As a dedicated coach, John led countless teams through seasons of growth and victory, but it was never just about winning. For him, it was about character. He believed that sports were not only an avenue for physical activity but a powerful tool for building confidence, resilience, and life skills. Generations of students were shaped by his enthusiastic cheers from the sidelines, his gentle corrections during drills, and the way he celebrated every improvement, no matter how small.
John McNally’s reach extended far beyond school walls. In the greater Ithaca athletics community, he was known and respected for his passionate support of youth sports, his collaborative spirit with fellow coaches, and his ability to bring people together through a shared love of movement and community. He was a mentor to young educators, a friend to parents, and a guide to students navigating both school and life.
His sudden passing has sent ripples of grief throughout the district. Tributes have poured in from students, former athletes, fellow teachers, and community members, all echoing the same sentiments: John was the kind of teacher who made you feel like you mattered. He brought light and warmth wherever he went, often without even realizing the scale of the impact he was having.
The McNally family has expressed deep gratitude for the overwhelming support during this difficult time. They are currently planning a memorial service and public tribute to celebrate John’s life, legacy, and the countless lives he touched. The event will be open to the community that John loved so dearly and devoted his life to serving.
John McNally’s legacy will live on in the halls of Boynton Middle School, on the fields where he coached, and in the hearts of the many young people he believed in. As Ithaca grieves, it also remembers and celebrates the incredible life of a man who spent every day lifting others up.
May we all carry forward his spirit—one of joy, compassion, and an unshakable belief in the power of people. Rest in peace, Coach McNally. Your legacy will never be forgotten.
Leave a Reply